E – 1742 Ethics: Determining Negligence in Engineering Failures
Intended Audience: All Engineers.
PDH UNITS: 2
PDH UNITS: 2
Negligence in the practice of professional engineering means the failure to behave with the standard of care that a professional engineer of ordinary prudence would have exercised under the same circumstances. The purpose of this course is to identify conditions under which, when an engineering failure has occurred, it can be attributed to negligence. Five causes of failure are proposed: negligence, rare failure mode, overlooked failure mode, new (previously unrecognized) failure mode, and incorrect assessment of a known risk. Negligence is the only cause that involves failing in an ethical duty.
These concepts are illustrated with five case studies of failures ranging from gross negligence to absolutely unforeseeable events:
- The Great Boston Molasses Flood of 1919, for which a new possible cause was identified 95 years later (2014);
- A building collapse in Bangladesh in which over 1,000 people died—one of the worst structural engineering disasters in history;
- A meteorite strike of a private residence;
- The crash of the British-French Concorde supersonic airliner, caused by an unlikely tire blow-out; and
- Radiation overdoses received by patients treated by the Thorac-25 medical linear accelerator, caused by errors in the software controlling the machine.
This course is intended for engineers concerned with ethical behavior in engineering practice.
This course is based on the paper, “Determining Negligence in Engineering Failures,” written by Mark Rossow, 2019.
At the successful conclusion of this course, you’ll be able to identify and discuss:
- Definition of negligence and standard of care
- Relation of safety and risk
- Knightian uncertainty
- Retrospective fallacy in accident investigations
- Myth of perfect engineering practice in accident investigations
- Uses and misuses of the results of failure investigations
- Negative effects of punishment on learning from accidents
- General causes of engineering failures